Why Seahawks OC Grubb? Macdonald Explains

Toimerologio

You need 5 min read

·

Post on Jan 07, 2025

41 visitor like this post

Share

Why Seahawks OC Grubb? Macdonald Explains the Rationale Behind the Hire

The Seattle Seahawks' decision to hire Shane Waldron as offensive coordinator in 2021 raised eyebrows. Now, with the appointment of Dave Canales to the same role, followed by the unexpected hiring of former 49ers quarterbacks coach, Brian Schottenheimer in 2023, and finally settling on former Carolina Panthers offensive coordinator, Thomas Brown in 2024, many are wondering about the team's offensive philosophy and the reasoning behind the choices. But the most recent appointment, the hiring of passing game coordinator and quarterbacks coach, Dave Canales for the Offensive Coordinator position in 2024, sparks even more intrigue. Why Dave Canales? And what does Head Coach Pete Carroll and General Manager John Schneider's selection say about the Seahawks' future offensive direction? To truly understand the Seahawks' offensive evolution, we need to delve into the rationale behind these hires, particularly focusing on the underlying principles and strategic vision of the team's leadership.

The Evolution of the Seahawks' Offensive Approach

The Seahawks' offensive identity has been in flux since the departure of offensive coordinator Darrell Bevell. While the team enjoyed sustained success under Bevell, a shift was needed to adapt to the evolving NFL landscape and the specific talents of their quarterbacks, notably Russell Wilson and now Geno Smith. Each offensive coordinator brought a different approach, leading to a period of experimentation and adjustment. Let's examine the key characteristics of each hire:

Shane Waldron (2021-2022): The Rams Influence

Waldron's hiring signaled a move towards a more modern, pass-heavy scheme influenced by his time with the Los Angeles Rams under Sean McVay. The emphasis shifted to utilizing play-action passes, incorporating pre-snap motion, and employing more sophisticated route concepts. While Waldron’s system showed flashes of brilliance, particularly with the designed rollouts for Russell Wilson, the transition wasn't seamless, and ultimately, his tenure was marked by inconsistencies.

Dave Canales (2023): A Return to Familiarity (and More)

Canales’ promotion to Offensive Coordinator in 2024 marks a fascinating return to a more familiar system. He has been an integral part of the Seahawks' coaching staff, serving as the quarterbacks coach and passing game coordinator. This experience allows for a deep understanding of the team's personnel and a continuity that can be crucial for success.

This isn't simply a case of "same old, same old," though. Canales' understanding of the offense, his working relationship with Geno Smith, and the evolution of the Seahawks’ roster indicates that while his scheme may draw upon elements of previous systems, the details will reflect adaptation and evolution. With the growth of players like Kenneth Walker III and DK Metcalf, the Seahawks' offense has evolved in its ability to mix and match both ground game and aerial attacks.

Understanding Pete Carroll's Vision

To truly appreciate the Seahawks' offensive coordinator choices, we must understand Pete Carroll's overarching philosophy. Carroll prioritizes a system that allows for adaptation and maximizes the strengths of his players. He emphasizes a strong running game to control the clock and maintain possession, a balance that keeps the defense guessing and ultimately helps them win games. He also values players with high football character and those who embrace the team culture.

This doesn't mean the Seahawks are averse to a strong passing attack. Rather, they seek an equilibrium, a blend of power running and creative passing plays that leverages the talents of their quarterbacks and receivers.

Why Dave Canales? A Deeper Dive

The choice of Dave Canales seems like a natural progression. His long-term presence in the organization suggests a familiarity and understanding that other candidates may not have possessed. His deep knowledge of the offensive system allows for a smoother transition, minimizing disruptions to the players and their respective comfort levels within the offense.

Furthermore, his close relationship with Geno Smith is an invaluable asset. The quarterback-coach dynamic plays a critical role in the success of an offense, and the existing rapport between Canales and Smith provides a foundation for continued growth and refinement. This familiarity translates into on-field efficiency and minimizes the potential for communication breakdowns.

Beyond familiarity, Canales brings several key attributes:

• Offensive Evolution: While building on the existing foundation, he’s also adaptable to evolving offensive trends in the NFL. The league is in constant change, and a coach who can recognize and integrate modern innovations is crucial for long-term competitiveness.
• Player Development: Canales has a proven track record in developing quarterbacks. His understanding of player tendencies, combined with his ability to cultivate talent, is integral to getting the most out of Geno Smith and other offensive players.
• Tactical Flexibility: A key aspect of the Seahawks’ success will depend upon their ability to adjust game plans based on game situations. Canales’s experience in different roles within the team should equip him well to adapt the offensive approach as needed.

The Long-Term Outlook

The Seahawks' commitment to continuity and gradual evolution suggests a long-term vision. They aren't looking for a quick fix; they're building a sustainable system that can support success for years to come. Dave Canales' appointment represents a commitment to player growth, offensive balance, and smart decision-making.

This focus on long-term development aligns perfectly with the Seahawks' overall team-building philosophy. The franchise culture emphasizes discipline, accountability, and a relentless focus on improvement. These values extend to the coaching staff and directly influence the choice of offensive coordinators.

Conclusion: A Calculated Risk with High Potential

The Seahawks' decision to appoint Dave Canales as Offensive Coordinator represents more than just a personnel change; it reflects a calculated strategy that prioritizes continuity, player development, and a sustainable offensive approach. While there's always an element of risk involved in any personnel decision, the team's track record suggests that this choice is grounded in careful consideration and a clear understanding of their long-term goals. The success of this approach will depend on several factors, including player performance, offensive line stability, and the continued evolution of Canales' offensive schemes. However, the team's decision reflects a considered gamble with the potential for significant rewards. The Seahawks aren't just reacting to changes; they’re proactively shaping their future. The appointment of Dave Canales may well become a defining moment in the next chapter of the Seahawks' offensive evolution.